CLOSED Giveaway: New Grain-Free Foods from Science Diet (4 winners!)

I learned that Purina One has very poor level of nutrients, not just poor ingredients.

I already know how good Science Diet is. My two basenjis have been eating it their entire lives. They are 12 years old and still act like puppies.

I would love to try the new formula – I’ve been feeding Purina One and am looking for something better for my cat with a sensitive tummy.

I’m glad to see Hill’s Science Diet is making a grain free dog food.

Nothing really surprized me but I do wonder where the “optimal range” came from.

Not too surprizing, I hope it tastes good.

Nice to compare, but I wonder what others that aren’t listed look like.

Lost 2 German Shepherd Dogs to cancer & so has my daughter, we wonder if it’s because of the grain in the dog food. Corn is a carb & not healthy.

If we win, we will donate the food to the pet food pantry or the Humane Society.

Nice to see more Grain Free Dog Food

It surprised me that their analysis is different that other sites.

I was surprised to see that it was somewhat comparable to my puppy’s premium food. I never thought Science Diet would come around!

I have never liked Science Diet because the ingredients were always poor. I wonder if there are any byproducts in this. Maybe their finally coming to their senses… If I win, I will donate it to my local humane society (North Texas).

*they’re

Was very disappointed to see that the Purina food I’ve fed my dog and cats is so low in nutrients. Not surprising, but happy to see Science Hill’s grain free dog food!

I’m surprised that they have more calcium than Blue Buffalo.

I didn’t realize how little nutrients other foods had.

I’d love to win this to give to my mom/my dog, Biscuit, the Pembroke Welsh Corgi!!!!

I would love to try their new food with some of my kittes or dogs!

It has fruits and veggies and has a beagle on a teetor totter. My 2 beagle Mixes would love to win a free bag to try. When I first had Roxy she ate science diet for a short time but then someone told me to switch her food to something better but this formula does sound better and like something my girls would love.

For being grain free it has all the nutrients & vitamins even more than the best dogs foods out there.

I am surprised to see Science Diet finally making a higher quality/comparable food.

There are actual vitamins in Science Diet foods.

Nothing really surprised me.
2dogs5catscrew@att.net

I had no ideal that Ideal Balance offered more key nutrients in comparison to Blue Buffalo & it’s grain-free!

I’m astounded their actually taking the step to a grain free diet. I’ll wait to see the ingredient list though before I commend them since the food could still be poor quality dispite grain free depending on what animal products are used.

I am surprised that it was better than the top quality dog foods.

I was surprised by the vitamin C and E in it

interesting to see the differences in dog food ingredients

TY for the contest!

I would love to try Grain Free on my doggies!

I was surprised to find out that iams is seriously lacking in the nutrient department.

Looking forward to using this new food! Thank you.

I was suprised it is much better for my pets then most people food is for me.

I was interested in the Blue Buffalo comparisons and that Science Diet was higher in many nutrient categories.

I am surprised to see Hill’s Science Diet Ideal Balance offering more nutrients than some very good brand. I am currently feeding Nutro Natural Choice but may switch to Ideal Balance giving this comparison.

I’m surprised on the whole that Science Diet was even capable of bringing out a decent food. The food looks pretty good and comparable to several of the better brands.

I hope I win this. My dog would LOVE it!!!!

Your Link to the Nutrient Comparison does not work. I read Susan Thixton’s The Truth About Pet Food, she is the only blogger asking big pet food companies the hard questions. Science Diet was part of the largest law suit in the history of this country, and my 2 cats died from eating their poison food. If that was not bad enough, after that the only KD food I could put them on was from Hills. They appear to have cleaned up their act, at least until the next big recall.

I’m really surprised that Ideal Balance is in the optimal range for all key nutrients, whereas the more expensive brand we’re currently using is not within optimal range for 4 of the 8 key nutrients

not necessarily, I would never feed Hills regardless of whether they omit grains or not, the food is incredibly overpriced for what it contains and all they did was substitute grain with potatoes, which are still high in sugar.

You need to look at the ingredients, for the quality its crappy and overpriced. Check out dogfoodadvisor.com and compare this food to 5 star kibbles.